Skip to content
21 June 2026

Keir Starmer’s Future in Doubt After Andy Burnham’s By-Election Victory

As Keir Starmer reflects on his political future, Andy Burnham emerges as a strong contender, while cabinet ministers weigh in on the leadership turmoil.

Keir Starmer's Future in Doubt After Andy Burnham's By-Election Victory

The political landscape in the UK is undergoing significant shifts as the Labour Party confronts internal strife and external pressures. The recent by-election victory of Andy Burnham in Makerfield has intensified speculation about the future of Prime Minister Keir Starmer’s leadership. As the party grapples with these challenges, the path forward remains uncertain.

In the wake of the Makerfield by-election, there is a palpable sense of change within the Labour Party. Many members and MPs have privately concluded that Starmer may not be the best candidate to lead the party into the next general election. The recent electoral losses and internal divisions have fueled this sentiment, prompting a search for new leadership.

Andy Burnham Emerges as a Strong Contender

Andy Burnham, the soon-to-be-former Greater Manchester mayor, is seen as a potential savior for the Labour Party. His victory in the Makerfield by-election has bolstered his standing within the party. Many believe that Burnham’s understanding of devolution and his ability to communicate effectively with voters could help Labour regain lost ground.

Burnham’s success in defeating Reform convincingly has also garnered attention. Even those who previously supported Wes Streeting as a potential leader are now considering Burnham as a viable alternative. His ability to appeal to both the left and the working-class base of the party is seen as a significant asset.

Cabinet Ministers Weigh In on Leadership Crisis

Business Secretary Peter Kyle has indicated that Starmer is reflecting on the political realities of his situation. Kyle described a frank conversation with the prime minister, emphasizing that Starmer is focused on the country’s interests rather than his own. This shift in tone suggests a recognition of the growing challenges Starmer faces.

Home Office minister Mike Tapp has suggested a legislative change to mandate a general election if a party forces a change of leader while in government. Tapp argues that this would prevent constant leadership churn and focus politicians on delivery rather than internal politics. However, this idea has faced criticism from some MPs who see it as an attempt to undermine the norms of parliamentary democracy.

The International Dimension: Trump’s Intervention

The leadership crisis has also drawn international attention. US President Donald Trump has weighed in on the situation, suggesting that Starmer will resign. Trump’s comments come amid a strained relationship between the two leaders, particularly over issues like immigration, energy policies, and the sovereignty of the Chagos Islands.

Downing Street has dismissed Trump’s intervention as speculation, stating that Starmer has not spoken to the president this weekend. However, the comments highlight the broader challenges Starmer faces, both domestically and internationally.

As the Labour Party navigates this turbulent period, the focus remains on how Starmer will respond to the mounting pressure. With key figures like Andy Burnham positioning themselves as potential leaders, the coming days will be crucial in determining the party’s future direction.

Author

Sophie Donovan

Sophie Donovan, Manchester-born and classically elegant, once turned down a commission to chase a long-form piece on Salford’s textile heritage, filing instead from the mill where her grandmother worked. Advocates patient, context-rich features and brings a taste for quiet narrative detail and theatre aficionadoship.