Netflix released Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story in September 2026, retelling the 1892 Fall River axe murders with a dramatized queer relationship and additional fictional violence in a series filmed and distributed on the streaming service.
The release mattered because it reframed a long-unsolved case involving the 1892 deaths of Andrew and Abby Borden and the subsequent 1893 trial of Lizzie Borden, adding invented incidents and a speculative romance that have reignited debates about the ethics of true-crime adaptations and historical fidelity; Last update: 26 September 2026.
Context: the historical case and the new interpretation
The original 1892 killings in Fall River left Andrew and Abby dead from axe wounds and produced a trial in which Lizzie was acquitted after a brief jury deliberation, a fact that the series retains while altering surrounding circumstances to create a coherent dramatic arc. The show adopts familiar documentary elements—the disputed purchase of poison, the burned dress and the lack of conclusive forensic evidence—but overlays them with invented motives and scenes, situating a speculative love affair at the heart of the narrative and presenting a version of events that departs from the archival record.
Creative liberties: invented murders, staging and anachronisms
The adaptation introduced several major departures from the historical record: an invented pre-murder killing of a neighbour named Bertha Manchester depicted as a rehearsal for the axe attacks despite historical timelines placing her death nine months later, and a dramatized scene in which pigeons are slaughtered by the stepmother to create a revenge motive. The writers also cast the protagonist as a suffragette figure, a political label not supported by period documents, and inserted an anachronistic dance sequence that pairs 1890s characters with a later-era duo set to 1984 synth-pop music; the latter choice intentionally links eras but diverges from documented fact.
The contested lesbian storyline and public response
The series frames Lizzie as secretly involved with the household maid Bridget Sullivan played on screen by Vicki Krieps a relationship that has no corroboration in trial transcripts or Sullivan’s testimony and that traces literary antecedents to a 1984 novel by Evan Hunter (writing as Ed McBain) which first posited a lesbian motive. The lead actor Ella Beatty defended the choice, saying the romance “opens up her eyes to the world and to herself” and describing her interpretation of the character as “vulnerable and soft”, and showrunners framed the device as a means to explore a theme they summarized as “female anger is not isolated to one era, it reverberates through history.”
Reactions from viewers, scholars and creators
Audience reactions split sharply, with some viewers praising the series’ bold aesthetic and emotional aims while critics and historians accused the production of sensationalising the real-life ambiguity and reinforcing harmful tropes that portray queer women as inherently dangerous. Commentators raised concerns that the anthology’s approach blurred the line between speculation and documented history by presenting invented murders and a fictional romance alongside verified facts, prompting renewed debate over platform responsibility when adapting unresolved or contested criminal cases.
Production statements and the broader true-crime debate
Producers defended creative choices as artistic interpretation: they described the anachronistic music and cross-era choreography as deliberate tools to bridge past and present and to visualise a recurring pattern of female violence as social symptom rather than individual pathology. At the same time, critics stressed that the series differs from previous anthology entries that focused on confessed killers and thus occupies a different ethical space when it projects specific, sensational motives onto figures whose historical culpability remains debated.
As audience discussion continued across social platforms and culture pages, the series renewed interest in the original case record—its circumstantial evidence, the purchase of prussic acid, the burned dress and the short jury deliberation—while also prompting calls for clearer distinctions between dramatized elements and verified facts in future adaptations. Last update: 26 September 2026.



