The U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit on Tuesday issued a mandate that prevents the Pentagon from removing the transgender service members who brought suit challenging President Donald Trump’s military directive. The order implements a June 1 opinion from the same panel and gives immediate protection to the troops named in the case while the administration pursues further review at the U.S. Supreme Court.
The plaintiffs are 27 active-duty personnel who, lawyers say, have amassed more than 130 years of combined service and received over 80 commendations. The Pentagon had placed those individuals on administrative leave and prepared some for military boards that could end their careers. The appeals court’s action bars any discharge of those plaintiffs while the litigation proceeds.
Legal background and earlier rulings
The litigation centers on an executive order signed in January 2025 and a Defense Department policy issued to implement it. The order stated that transgender service members undermine military readiness and discipline, and the policy from Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth set a presumption that people diagnosed with gender dysphoria are disqualified from service. Gender dysphoria is the medical term for the distress some people experience when their assigned gender at birth does not match their gender identity.
In March 2025, U.S. District Judge Ana Reyes found the executive order likely violated the Constitution and issued an injunction that protected currently serving transgender troops from discharge. The D.C. Circuit issued a partial ruling on June 1 that agreed the policy was designed to exclude based on gender identity and preserved protections for those already serving, while lifting the block on new enlistments.
Appeals court mandate and judges’ opinions
A three-judge panel considered the government’s request to stay the June 1 mandate while it seeks Supreme Court review. The panel rejected that request by a 2-1 vote. Circuit Judge Robert Wilkins wrote that the government failed to show that keeping the plaintiffs in uniform would cause irreparable harm to national security or other government interests. Judge Judith Rogers joined part of Wilkins’s opinion.
In contrast, Circuit Judge Justin Walker dissented from the denial, arguing that courts lack authority to second-guess military decisions about personnel. Walker would have granted the stay the administration sought. Wilkins observed that the government had multiple opportunities to identify a concrete readiness risk but relied on general assertions of national security instead.
Scope of the court’s protection
The appeals panel’s mandate enforces the narrower June 1 ruling. That means the order shields the named plaintiffs from discharge, but it does not permit new transgender recruits to enlist. The mandate affected at least 27 service members in the suit; their counsel emphasized that the government has conceded they met military standards and served honorably.
Ongoing litigation and procedural next steps
The administration has filed a petition asking the U.S. Supreme Court to consider the case. The Supreme Court distributed that petition for its December 4 conference, where justices will decide whether to take the matter. Meanwhile, the district judge handling the underlying trial, Ana Reyes, is moving forward with pretrial orders. She has required the government to produce internal records about the policy and authorized depositions of former officials, including a former Army secretary, under oath.
The trial remains scheduled to begin on January 4. Judge Reyes has indicated she may certify a class of affected service members, a step that would broaden the practical reach of any final judgment beyond the plaintiffs who filed the suit. The appeals panel’s mandate preserves the status of the 27 named troops during these proceedings.
Arguments presented by the parties
The government has defended the policy as a medical and readiness standard and urged deference to military leaders on personnel decisions. The plaintiffs’ lawyers argued the policy is discriminatory because it excludes people on the basis of their gender identity and applies categorical disqualifications that override commanders’ personnel judgments. Counsel pointed to text in the policy that treated social transition or prior use of different pronouns as disqualifying factors for waiver consideration.
Advocates for the plaintiffs described the service members in the case as decorated and fully qualified under military standards. The appeals court’s refusal to delay its mandate leaves those individuals able to remain in uniform as the dispute continues through the courts.



